Replacement cost vs. actual cash value

If you’ve ever bought insurance, you’ve probably heard of replacement cost and actual cash value. But what do they actually mean for your policy?

You need to know these two terms and what they mean to understand the fine print when buying insurance. Here’s where to start.

Replacement cost

When your policy covers replacement cost, it refers to replacing the item you’re insuring. For example, if you were to insure your roof for replacement cost, it would cover replacing the roof to its original condition (a new roof). It could also cover buying new items similar in kind and quality to the original item. For example, say you had a 10-year-old refrigerator. With replacement cost, you would receive enough to buy a brand new refrigerator of a similar model even though yours is 10 years old.

This obviously has advantages when collecting a payout but it may come with slightly higher premiums than an actual car value policy.

Actual cash value (ACV)

A policy that covers actual cash value is a little different. It takes depreciation into account.

Where replacement cost covers replacing items as they would have been in their original condition, actual cash value covers replacing items in their current condition. For example, if you were to try to replace a 10-year-old roof with ACV, the value of the roof in its current condition could be thousands less due to depreciation.

Actual cash value may be cheaper than replacement cost, but it can be much less helpful if you’re trying to replace something expensive. Some homeowners have been rudely shocked when they realized that they thought their roof was covered under replacement value when they’d actually taken out an ACV policy.

Which is better?

Replacement cost is almost always better than ACV. ACV may not cost as much in premium as replacement cost, but you need to consider if the cost savings is worth the risk and hassle of receiving a significantly reduced payout at the time of claim. Talk to your broker about what works best for you.

Need a hand choosing the right policy? We can help. MVP Insurance can guide you toward the right insurance for you. Contact us today.

Joan Curtis

Co-owner/Licensed Agent

What do you enjoy most about working at MVP Insurance?


I love working with such an amazing team!  As an owner here, I get the blessing of choosing who I get to work with every day, and I have to say I would put our team up against any!  We are blessed to have people who put service before self daily!  Second, I love that we get to honor God with what we do here.  I don’t want to live a day without the Lord being a part of our business.  I believe that is one of the biggest reasons we have been successful in this industry!


What is your favorite book, movie, and/or Song?


My favorite Movie – Is Pride and Prejudice (2005)

My favorite song is . . . all of them!  I love all music except for maybe Death Metal!

My favorite book series that I have read recently is “The Prison Healer” series by Lynette Noni.  I love listening to young adult fiction the best.  Gets me out of my head and I get to take mini adventures with the characters.


Another series I really enjoyed was “Legend” by Marie Lu.  Both have amazing character development and unique surprises. A business book that I recently listened to that was amazing was Overcoming the Five Dysfunctions of a Team by Patrick Lencioni.

 

What is your Favorite Quote or Scripture?


Colossians 3:4 “When Christ, who is your life, appears, then you also will appear with him in glory.”  This is one of God’s promises when you live for the Lord, not everyone will understand that, and that’s okay, I am not for everybody.  I am for the ONE!


What is your dream Vacation?


My dream vacation would be to travel in the Mediterranean with my husband and all my kids and their families, for like 3 months and really get to experience the culture and the beauty there.

Blythe Donovan

Licensed Agent

How did you get into Insurance?


I got into insurance in 2019 because God told me this was my next step when I came in to meet with Brent and Joan for the first time! I love being an insurance agent because I get to help educate people and help protect families. I love my job for so many reasons, but mostly because I work with incredible people, both at MVP and with the relationships I form with clients and referral partners.


What is your favorite book, movie, and/or Song?


I don’t know if I can choose an actual favorite, because I love so many things in life! But the song that brings me the most joy currently is Somewhere Over the Rainbow/Wonderful World medley by IZ, with the ukulele. I love the words, the hopeful message, and I tend to always find the silver lining or the other side of the rainbow in every situation. I am an incurable optimist and joy seeker!


What is your Favorite Quote or Scripture?


My favorite scripture is Ephesians 3:20, God is able to do exceedingly, and abundantly, more than we can ask or imagine!


What is your dream Vacation?


My dream vacation is a quiet place in the mountains! My husband and I took a belated honeymoon to Pagosa Springs, Colorado and it was a slice of heaven on earth! My ideal day would be spent outdoors, enjoying wildflowers, the sound of a river rushing by, cool mountain breezes, and the smell of pine trees. We loved the small town and beauty of Pagosa Springs so much that we are actively working towards being able to get a place there so we can escape to the mountains more regularly!

Jade Griggs

Client Concierge

What do you enjoy most about working at MVP Insurance?


I love how everyone in the office is like family! I learn something new every day.


What is your favorite book, movie, and/or Song?


Favorite Book: Anything by Tracy Wolff 

Favorite Movie: “White Christmas” and “Dirty Dancing”. 

Favorite Music; Christmas, Country, Christian

 

What is your Favorite Quote or Scripture?


 Favorite Quote: Today is only one day in all the days that will ever be. But what will happen in all the other days that ever come can depend on what you do today! -Ernest Hemingway.


Favorite Scripture: so do not fear, for I am with you; do not be dismayed, for I am your God. I will strengthen you and help you; I will uphold you with my righteous right hand. – Isaiah 41:10

 

What is your dream Vacation?


My childhood dream vacation was to go to Disney World (like most little kids). However, as an adult my ultimate vacation would be to travel to Ireland and visit the many towns, and villages along the western shoreline. The most famous landmark in Ireland is probably the Cliffs of Moher which is at the top of my bucket list.

Brent Brown

Co-Owner / Licensed Agent

What do you enjoy most about working at MVP Insurance?

 

I love the family atmosphere that we have created here at MVP. Everyone is willing to go the extra mile to help a fellow client, co-worker, or strategic partner!

 

What is your favorite book, movie, and/or Song?

 

If you catch me reading it is most likely a book about business or personal development. One of my all time favorites is “Good to Great” by Jim Collins. I don’t think I can pick a favorite movie, but I am a huge fan of “The Office” TV Series (American Version). I like to think I’m a Jim, but truthfully, I’m probably more of a Michael!

 

I enjoy listening to all genres of music. People who ride with me are often taken aback because I’ll be streaming Beethoven from my phone and an EMINEM song will come on after.

 

What is your Favorite Quote or Scripture?

 

“I can do all things through Christ who strengthens me” Philippians 4:13
“An office is for not dying. An office is a place to live life to the fullest, to the max. An office is a place where dreams come true.“ Michael Scott

 

What is your dream Vacation?

 

Snow Skiing and a big cabin in the Mountains of Colorado!